Total judging points: 19
Judge's Comments:
#1 This is a very good image with even greater potential. This viewer suggests increasing the exposure very slightly. Then dodge the roses a little bit to highlight them and to further separate them from the background. Burn-in the distracting out-of-focus lamps in the background. Also burn the light spots on the background building as well as the hanging objects in the upper left background. Consider cropping down from the top of the image to just below the blurry white line and up from the bottom to just below the lowest leaves. My suggestions are a matter of taste. You have a potentially strong image, but you must eliminate or reduce the out-of-focus items in the background.
#2
#3 Cropping from the top could help bring out the subject.
#4 A dark moody image with red roses. The 5 bright spots draw my attention away from the roses. The background in the upper third of the images is a distraction from the roses.